Keenan experience a lesson for America
(by Liam Clarke, News Letter)
I can remember the ripple ran that round the press gallery at the opening of the Northern Ireland Assembly just over a year ago when Brian Keenan was spotted sitting in the honoured guests section along with other IRA leaders.
“Is that Keenan? Is that Storey beside him?” colleagues hissed. It seemed remarkable at the time, for in the past these men would normally have been stopped by security like Michael Stone; afterwards, the Assembly authorities insisted that a full guest list wasn’t available.
Once the initial frisson of excitement and scramble to put names to faces, had died down their presence was reassuring. The sight of Keenan craning forward like a tourist for a better look at Ian Paisley was a sign that the deal would indeed stick.
Jonathan Powell, who was sitting just feet away from Keenan, later described him as the most dangerous threat to the British state during the IRA bombing campaign in London in the 1970s but added “he was also instrumental in bringing the IRA round to a political strategy”.
Keenan’s long illness began in July 2002, when he was diagnosed with stomach cancer after complaining of what he thought was a bowel infection. “If he had died it might not have been possible to persuade the IRA to trade the armalite for the ballot box” Powell said.
He was the intermediary with General John de Chastelain’s decommissioning body. They gave him the code name “O’Neill”, in reference to the P. O’Neill signature which appears at the end of the IRA statements.
Keenan was an intelligent man who spoke French, Arabic and Spanish. He was an avowed Marxist who held East Germany out as an example of what a united Ireland would be like. It was Keenan who, through his international contacts, forged links with Libya and later with the FARC terrorists in Colombia in an attempt to arm the IRA for the long haul.
He organised the 1970s IRA bombing campaign which culminated in the Balcombe Street Siege where his finger prints were found on documents. During a brief ceasefire in 1976 he backed hardline units to carry out sectarian atrocities in South Armagh, including the Kingsmills massacre.
In 1979 he was finally arrested after meeting Martin McGuinness, who was under surveillance, on the way to scout a bombing. During his 18 year sentence Keenan speculated to other prisoners that McGuinness may have betrayed him, but he dropped the matter after his released. Still, he must have had mixed emotions as he watched the Deputy First Minister from the Stormont gallery.
Keenan left no statesmanlike or visionary speeches – they are all filled with threats and hatred. This made him the ideal man to put an uncompromising face on what would otherwise have looked like defeat.
George Bush may wish to look at this example when he visits Northern Ireland next month to encourage investment and take his share of the credit for the success of the peace process.
All this is to be welcomed. The ending of the troubles had many causes, but American “soft power” – the use of diplomatic and economic influence – helped to chop years off the conflict. There is no underestimating the success of the security forces in closing down the options of men like Keenan, but diplomatic pressure and patient persuasion finally talked them down from the ledge and made them persuaders for a deal they had wasted their youths rejecting.
Yet Bush and John McCain, the Republican candidate for the presidency, have described proposals from Barack Obama for talks with Cuba, Iran and Hamas as comparable to the attempted appeasement of Hitler prior to the Second World War.
The analogy breaks down because the appeasement of Hitler was a cave in to military pressure from a dictator who was attempting to overrun large sections of Europe. Cuba, Iran and even Hamas are not in this league. The US is the most powerful country on earth. These countries have no missiles that could reach its shores but it could, if it was prepared for the price, bomb any of them into submission. They know this, just as Keenan knew, after a lifetime’s bitter experience, that the security forces had the upper hand.
This is a good time for the US to talk quietly and carry a big stick. The other approach has, as Obama put it, “left the country with two wars and a battered economy”.
May 22, 2008
________________
This article appeared in the May 22, 2008 edition of the News Letter.


'So venceremos, beidh bua againn eigin lá eigin. Sealadaigh abú.'
--Bobby Sands