Can we ever let go of our dark past?
Tory councillor Mari Gatland is an example of someone who has paid her dues for her 1970s IRA affiliation
Liam Clarke
The Times
7 Dec 2008
Maria Gatland, a Dubliner living in Surrey, clearly regrets the year she spent as a member of Sinn Fein and the IRA. Her case raises, in a particularly acute form, the question of when someone has the right to put their past behind them.
Gatland has suffered for her youthful republican affiliations. In the 1970s she was placed under a death threat and banned from entering Switzerland after admitting involvement in moving money for the purchase of weapons. “It was a painful and traumatic time for me and it took me many years to recover from it and closed many doors to me,” she told me last week.
Nowadays, she looks nothing like an IRA woman. Until last week she was a prominent Tory councillor who sat on Croydon council as the cabinet member for education. Gatland was outed after Dr Peter Latham referred to her as “councillor McGuire” (her maiden name) and wondered aloud whether, since she was Irish, she knew much about a book he had been reading about a year in the IRA.
“I didn’t know when I went into the meeting if it was definitely her or not,” said Latham, who was trying to force a vote on local education cuts. “Had she agreed to the ballots, I don’t think I would have mentioned anything about the book.”
It gave the Daily Mirror the sort of headline a Labour-leaning newspaper can usually but dream of: “Top Tory quits in IRA shame”. Gatland’s resignation from the party was demanded by Mike Fisher, the Conservative leader of the council, who gave the Croydon Advertiser an interview that reads, in places, like a script from Little Britain. “Councillor Gatland telephoned me this morning . . . She said she had been a member of the Provisional IRA and had been active at the time,” he said. “We do ask if they are a member of another party, but how can you check up if somebody has a history like this?”
He accused her of a betrayal of trust: the charge levelled by the IRA when Gatland published her kiss and tell account of her time with them in 1973. The Provos suspected she had been debriefed by British intelligence. Sean MacStiofain, the IRA chief of staff, who died in 2001, took a firmer line than Fisher: he warned Gatland that if she returned to Ireland she would face an IRA court martial and the penalty was likely to be death.
With MacStiofain, it was personal as well as political. McGuire’s book, To Take Arms, portrays him as a narrow-minded fanatic who was sniggered at and called “Mad Jack” behind his back. She even relates how he had secretly eaten steak while supposedly on hunger strike in prison.
All this may explain why McGuire decided not to publicise her past after she became a Tory matron in the shires. She did tell Mervyn Gatland, whom she married in 1976. He wanted to become a Tory councillor but died after a lung transplant in 2000 and she decided to enter politics in his place.
Like many young people in conflict situations, McGuire joined a terrorist group on the spur of the moment. A wealthy Dublin socialite from a respectable family, she phoned RTE with a request to be put in contact with Sean O Bradaigh, Sinn Fein’s director of publicity, after hearing him being interviewed.
After meeting her, O Bradaigh contacted MacStiofain, who recorded his impressions in Memoirs of a Revolutionary. “She was a university graduate, then aged about 23, and was supposed to be a linguist. It was felt that she might be able to contribute useful work.” She sensed he was a bit taken aback — “possibly he wasn’t expecting someone wearing hot pants to be interested in the Provisional IRA”.
Dave O’Connell (better known as Daithi O Conaill), a veteran of the 1950s campaign and a member of the Army Council, was more enthusiastic. He slept with her — and the pillow talk was fascinating. O’Connell talked of murdering MacStiofain and taking control of the IRA with her at his side.
A month after Bloody Sunday, he dispatched her to the north west, where Gatland spent days talking to local IRA members in Derry and Donegal before reporting back to O’Connell. The most sensational episode was an arms-buying expedition which degenerated into a binge of sex and drink conducted in European hotels at the IRA’s expense. The outcome was that 166 crates of bazookas, rocket launchers, grenades, rifles and ammunition, all paid for by the IRA, were seized at Schiphol airport in Amsterdam.
O’Connell and McGuire fled to Ireland where an IRA court of inquiry blamed the security lapse on Omnipol, the Czech state arms manufacturer which supplied many of the weapons. Sinn Fein made the best of the debacle, presenting McGuire and O’Connell as heroes for evading British intelligence and escaping to Dublin. The affair with O’Connell became common knowledge, but, McGuire wrote in her book: “He wasn’t worried by the newspaper reports of how many beds had been used, so long as they didn’t discover all the whiskey bottles underneath them.”
Disillusion set in as the indiscriminate nature of the IRA campaign became clear. The last straw came on July 21, 1972, Bloody Friday, when at least 22 car bombs detonated in Belfast killing 11 people and injuring 130. McGuire confided her doubts to Colin Smith, a journalist, who took her to England. Before leaving she dumped her IRA-issue Walther pistol in the women’s toilets at Dublin airport.
It has all the makings of a blockbuster movie, but it is a long time ago. Gatland did do her best to make amends by telling what she knew about the IRA. As Iain Duncan Smith, the former Conservative leader, pointed out, she is not wanted for any crime and, in security terms, it is understandable that she did not make her past public. “It was so long ago that I felt I could do something that used such talents that I have, and make some kind of difference to the community where I live,” she told me last week.
All over Ireland people, often with a much more serious paramilitary past, are struggling to be re-integrated into society. Our attitude to them is not always thought out or joined up. Some are hounded, others hold public office. Martina Anderson, a former bomber who got a degree in prison, sits on the Northern Ireland Policing Board but cannot be employed as a teacher. Gerry Kelly, another former bomber, is a minister who could not work as a civil servant. Kelly recently boasted on television of shooting a prison officer in the face during a prison break, yet no questions were raised about his fitness to act as Sinn Fein’s justice spokesman.
Last week it was disclosed that Sean O’Callaghan, who carried out two murders in Omagh on behalf of the IRA in the 1970s but later became a garda informer and confessed to his crimes, had been paid £80,000 (€92,500) by the Omagh Victims’ Legal Fund for lobbying on its behalf.
Anthony McIntyre, who served 18 years for the murder of two loyalists, was denied entry to America to promote a book which called for an end to republican violence. Gerry Adams, however, comes and goes as he wishes and last month Nelson McCausland, a DUP Assembly member, was thrown out of the chamber for using privilege to accuse the Sinn Fein president of involvement in IRA activity. McCausland said he was merely echoing statements by Irish ministers and the contents of books available in the Assembly library.
There is no consistency here, but the need to draw a line under the past with fairness and equity is obvious. If the strange case of Maria Gatland/McGuire serves to open up a debate on how and when we can allow people to move on, then Dr Peter Latham and the Save Our Schools campaign in Croydon has done us all a great service.

She met the man, whom she later found out was one of the killers, at the Pompidou Centre in Paris. She’d been told he could help. Her instructions were to stand at a certain book rack in the library and he would approach. Her Irish boyfriend had been missing for a month and she was out of her mind with worry.
What S didn’t tell Moore was that her boyfriend was about 100 miles from Paris, lying in a forest near the town of Pont de l’Arche in Normandy. It was a far from peaceful resting place. The first time the grave was so shallow that deer pawed up the body, exposing a limb. So the killers went back, moved Séamus, and buried him again.
“The Eiffel Tower, the Arc de Triomphe, Notre Dame, we did it all. At night, he laughed at us trying to eat frogs’ legs. We spent a wonderful evening in a café on Rue Saint-Denis. I treasure those photographs.”
The 55-year-old Brennan had been working as a carpenter, living openly in the San Francisco area for ten years, where he had also married an American woman named Joanna Volz.

'So venceremos, beidh bua againn eigin lá eigin. Sealadaigh abú.'
--Bobby Sands